Concept


In addition to the set of chromosomes found in the nucleus, a different type of chromosome is found in the energy-generating organelles of the cytoplasm, the mitochondria. The mitochondrial (mt) chromosome contains genes involved in the process of oxidative phosphorylation — the production and storage of energy. There is evidence that mitochondria once existed as free-living bacteria, which were taken up by primitive ancestors of eukaryotic cells. The primitive host cell provided a ready source of energy-rich nutrients, and the mitochondrion provided a means to extract energy using oxygen. This symbiotic relationship became key to survival, as oxygen accumulated in the primitive atmosphere. Mitochondria are physically similar in size to bacteria, and the mt genome retains bacteria-like features. Like bacterial chromosomes, the mt genome is a circular molecule. Also, very few introns are found in mt genes. Plants contain an additional ancient chromosome in the chloroplasts, which were also absorbed as symbionts.

Animation


Hi, I'm Herman Muller. When I worked with Thomas Hunt Morgan in the early 1900's, we occasionally found mutant flies – including the famous white-eyed fly. We knew the mutants must be due to spontaneous mutations in genes. Although mutations are essential to understanding normal gene function, they are extremely rare events. I searched the literature and found hints that X-rays damage the chromosomes. I figured X-rays must cause mutations and might be used to quickly induce new mutations in fruit flies. In the 1920's, I set up an experiment to look for lethal mutations induced by X-rays. I used a special strain of female flies that carried a lethal recessive mutation – called – on one X chromosome. The females live because their other X chromosome has a normal copy of the gene. In the first cross, I mated these l females with males whose sperm had been bombarded with X-rays. I designed the experiment to detect a mutation ( m ) induced by X-rays in the X chromosome, but mutations can occur anywhere. The male progeny that inherit the l gene die because they don't have another X chromosome to carry a normal copy of the gene. In the second cross, I mated daughters containing the l gene with wildtype males. Like the previous cross, males with the l gene died. Males that inherited the X-rayed chromosome also died if m was a lethal mutation. When I found no males in the second cross, I showed that X-rays could induce mutations. Using different levels of X-ray exposure, we could make mutants that didn't die, but we still didn't know what a mutation was, or even what a gene looked like. Hi, I'm Seymour Benzer. Until the 1950s, most people thought genes resembled beads in a string. That is, genes were indivisible, and crossing over could only occur between the genes. After Watson and Crick published their DNA model, I realized that if a gene was a sequence of bases it could be divisible at many different locations. And crossing over could occur within a gene. This is shown on the right where the chromosomes crossed over within the 'E' gene. In bead theory, shown on the left, the chromosomes crossed over between the 'E' and 'F' genes. I demonstrated the gene's divisibility by crossing different virus mutants. Each mutant came from a different viral culture, but all had a defective rII gene. After both mutants inject their DNA into a bacteria cell, some DNA from mutant #104 crosses over with DNA from mutant #51, and the bacterium replicates the viral DNA. In the gene-as-a-bead theory, all of the recombinant DNA would get a defective rII gene. But I found recombinant DNA that did not have a mutated rII gene. This happened because the DNA crossed over in the middle of the rII gene. In this example,crossing over occurred between the two adenines in the rII gene. The recombinant that didn't receive the mutations from its "parents" ended up with a wildtype rII sequence. I made a map of the locations of these mutations in the rII gene by counting the number of wildtype offspring produced in many different crosses – the same method Alfred Sturtevant used to map the location of different genes. With this map of mutations in the rII gene, I tried to discover the minimum number of altered nucleotides that are required to make one mutation. My map, combined with other work, showed that only one nucleotide change is needed to make a mutation. These single changes are called point mutations. For example, virus mutant #104 has a point mutation where adenine replaces cytosine. Point mutations cause only one amino acid change in the protein made from the gene. Other base changes cause frameshift mutations. Insertions or deletions of one or more bases alter the reading frame in the DNA sequence and cause changes in many amino acids.

Gallery


First page of Muller's 1921 paper on variations.
A young Hermann Muller.
Herman Muller's high school photo.
Hermann Muller in his lab in Austin.
Hermann Muller in Austin, circa 1920s.
Hermann Muller teaching a class at Indiana University.
Hermann Muller receiving his Nobel Prize from the King of Sweden, 1946.
Hermann Muller and some of his staff in the Fly room at Indiana University.
Alfred Hershey and Seymour Benzer at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, 1953 Symposium.
Seymour Benzer with a tube of Drosophila.
Seymour Benzer in labcoat.

Audio/Video


Audio Glossary

Base pair, Deletion, Dominant, Gene, Inherited, Insertion, Mutation, Recessive

Video Interviews

Elof Carlson

Elof Carlson is Distinguished Teaching Professor at the State University of New York, Stony Brook. A geneticist with an interest in the history of science, Dr. Carlson was one of Hermann Muller's graduate students.

Clip 1 (0:40)
Muller's reductionist approach to science.

Clip 2 (1:34)
Muller's construction and use of sex-linked lethals in Drosophila.

Clip 3 (0:56)
The importance of Muller's paper on X-ray mutations, part 1.

Clip 4 (1:42)
The importance of Muller's paper on X-ray mutations, part 2.

Clip 5 (1:01)
The importance of Muller's paper on X-ray mutations, part 3.

Clip 6 (1:32)
Muller's views on eugenics.

Svante Paabo

Svante Paabo is the Director of the Department of Evoluntionary Genetics at the Max Planck Institute. He uses mutations to look at human evolution.

Clip 1 (0:41)
How can one use mutations to track human evolution?

Clip 2 (0:40)
What molecular genetics tells us about the Neandertal relationship to modern humans.

Biography


 

Hermann Muller received the 1946 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his work on mutations induced by X-rays. Seymour Benzer used genetics to prove that mutations were caused by changes in the DNA sequence.

HERMANN MULLER (1890-1967)

Hermann Muller was born in Manhattan in 1890 and grew into a 5'2" science geek. His father, who casted statues at Muller Art Metal Works, influenced Hermann with his socialist ideals and a love of science. As a boy, Hermann spent summers hiking in the Adirondack Mountains and spent nights pondering how life would be on the planets he viewed through his telescope.

Upon graduation from Morris High School in 1907 at age sixteen, Muller attended Columbia University and was attracted to the emerging field of genetics.

He remained at Columbia for graduate school where he spent time in T.H. Morgan's Drosophila lab. Muller joined Morgan's other students in stealing small milk bottles from apartment steps to house the flies. But Muller clashed with Morgan and his student, Alfred Sturtevant, because Muller felt that they did not fully acknowledge his ideas in their papers.

Consequently, Muller appears on few papers that came from the Fly Lab except his own. In one paper, Muller showed that mutations in one gene could alter the expression of another gene, implying that many fly characteristics depend on several interacting genes. He left the lab in 1915 after receiving his degree and eventually joined the faculty at the University of Texas.

In the 1920s, Muller performed his Nobel prize-winning research showing that X-rays could induce mutations and he became instantly famous. Muller used his fame to caution against the indiscriminate use of X-rays in medicine, but despite his warnings, some physicians even prescribed X-rays to stimulate ovulation in sterile women. His warnings angered many doctors and were largely ignored.

Muller's outspoken views on socialism also got him in trouble with the Texas administration. He helped publish a Communist newspaper at the school, and the FBI tracked his activities. Feeling that U.S. society was regressing during the Depression, Muller left for Europe in 1932.

A move to the Soviet Union in 1934 seemed to have cured Muller of his Communist sympathies, although he always remained a socialist. Initially happy with the progressive society, he wrote popular articles praising the friendly people and the initiative of collective farm workers. But he grew unhappy as Stalin's police state attacked genetics by pushing Lamarkian ideas of evolution. The state dictated who could work in his lab and questioned him for referring to the work of Germans or Russian emigrés. By the time he left in 1937, several of his students and colleagues had "disappeared" or been shipped to Siberia.

Muller spent eight weeks in Spain helping the International Brigade develop a way to get blood for transfusions from recently killed soldiers, and then worked at the University of Edinburgh where he continued to work on X-rays and other mutagens like UV and mustard gas.

World War II forced Muller to leave Scotland in 1940 and he eventually found a permanent position at Indiana University in 1945. A year later, Muller won the Nobel Prize for his work on mutation-inducing X-rays and he used the opportunity to continue pressing for more public knowledge about the hazards of X-ray radiation.

Throughout his career, Muller felt scientists should get involved in educating the public. Not only was he outspoken about the effects of radiation, he also fought against the Texas school board's attacks on evolution. He promoted his view of eugenics - though he criticized the American eugenics movement for its racism and classism - and recommended voluntary reproduction through artificial insemination for families with genetic disorders.

Muller died in 1967 of congestive heart failure.

SEYMOUR BENZER (1921-)

Seymour Benzer was born in 1921 and grew up in the Bensonhurst neighborhood of Brooklyn, NY. His parents emigrated from Warsaw, Poland and worked in the garment industry. Although his family was not interested in science, Benzer dissected flies in his basement lab and read books on atomic physics during synagogue.

At 15, Benzer graduated from high school and studied physics and chemistry at Brooklyn College on a Regents Scholarship. He continued his study of physics in graduate school at Purdue University where he worked on a secret military radar project.

Later in grad school, Benzer read a short book called What is Life?, the same book that turned James Watson from ornithology to his quest for the structure of DNA. Erwin Schrodinger's book had a similar effect on Benzer because it made the mysterious nature of genes sound like the problem to solve. Benzer took the summer bacteriophage course at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory in 1948 with Gunther Stent. After struggling to learn the course's most important skill - holding a test tube in one hand and the test tube cap and pipette in the other - Benzer was hooked on biology.

Benzer returned to Purdue as a professor of physics, but spent most of his time travelling to other labs to work in molecular biology. In 1953, after Watson and Crick published their model of DNA, Benzer hatched his plan to get inside the gene by using bacteriophage with mutant rII genes. Max Delbrück ridiculed the plan and told Benzer "you must have drunk a triple highball before writing this." Benzer's 5-year-old daughter Martha liked the plan better and sketched her vision of two phages infecting a bacterium. In 1971, Benzer received the Lasker Award for this "brilliant contribution to molecular genetics."

After ten years of work on the rII system, and prompted by observations of his two daughters, Benzer began studying how genes shape behavior. As a professor of biology at Caltech, he and his graduate student Ronald Konopka were the first to find a gene that controls an organism's sense of time. Benzer received the Crafoord Prize in 1993 for his pioneering work in genes and behavior.

Benzer currently works on genes and aging in fruit flies with support from the Ellison Medical Foundation Senior Scholars in Aging Program. When he's not spending the night working in his lab (he thinks he's a clock mutant), he's been caught warming up a lunch of cow's udder or bull testicles on his Bunsen burner, prying open locked doors, and playing with his plastic eyeball keychain.

Factoid

Links


 

Links

Dr. Seymour Benzer's Laboratory Homepage

X-rays

Physics 2000, an interactive guide to modern physics from the University of Colorado, brings physics to life. Learn about X-rays in Einstein's Legacy.

Why so many errors in our DNA?

A nice summary on the how and why of DNA mutations from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Blazing a Genetic Trail web site.

Bibliography

  • Carlson, Elof Axel, 1981, Genes, Radiation and Society: the Life and Work of H.J. Muller, Cornell University Press, New York.

  • Friedberg, Errol C., 1997, Correcting the Blueprint of Life: An Historical Account of the Discovery of DNA Repair Mechanisms, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press, Cold Spring Harbor.

  • Muller, H., 1927, Artificial Transmutation of the Gene, Science, 66: 84-87.

  • Rupert, Claud S., Goodgal, Sol H., and Herriott, Roger M., 1958, Photoreactivation in vitro of Ultraviolet Inactivated Hemophilus influenzae Transforming Factor, Journal of General Physiology, 41: 451-471.

  • Setlow, Richard B., 1997, DNA Damage and Repair: A Photobiological Odyssey, Photochemistry and Photobiology, 65S: 119S-122S.

  • Snustad, D. Peter, Simmons, Michael J., and Jenkins, John B., 1997, Principles of Genetics, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.

  • Griffiths, Anthony J.F., et al., 1996, An Introduction to Genetic Analysis, W.H. Freeman and Company, New York.

  • Judson, Horace Freeland, 1979, The Eighth Day of Creation: Makers of the Revolution in Biology, Simon and Schuster, New York.

  • Weiner, Jonathan, 1999, Time, Love, Memory: A Great Biologist and His Quest for the Origins of Behavior, Alfred A. Knopf, New York.

Glossary


Base pair - Two bases which form a "rung of the DNA ladder." A DNA nucleotide is made of a molecule of sugar, a molecule of phosphoric acid, and a molecule called a base. The bases are the "letters" that spell out the genetic code. In DNA, the code letters are A, T, G, and C, which stand for the chemicals adenine, thymine, guanine, and cytosine, respectively. In base pairing, adenine always pairs with thymine, and guanine always pairs with cytosine.
Deletion - A particular kind of mutation: loss of a piece of DNA from a chromosome. Deletion of a gene or part of a gene can lead to a disease or abnormality.
Dominant - A gene that almost always results in a specific physical characteristic, for example, a disease, even though the patient's genome possesses only one copy. With a dominant gene, the chance of passing on the gene (and therefore the disease) to children is 50-50 in each pregnancy.
Gene - The functional and physical unit of heredity passed from parent to offpsring. Genes are pieces of DNA, and most genes contain the information for making a specific protein.
Inherited - Transmitted through genes from parents to offspring.
Insertion - A type of chromosomal abnormality in which a DNA sequence is inserted into a gene, disrupting the normal structure and function of that gene.
Mutation - A permanent structural alteration in DNA. In most cases, such DNA changes either have no effect or cause harm, but occasionally a mutation can improve an organism's chance of surviving and passing the beneficial change on to its descendants.
Recessive - A genetic disorder that appears only in patients who have received two copies of a mutant gene, one from each parent.

Children resemble their parents.
Genes come in pairs.
Genes don't blend.
Some genes are dominant.
Genetic inheritance follows rules.
Genes are real things.
All cells arise from pre-existing cells.
Sex cells have one set of chromosomes; body cells have two.
Specialized chromosomes determine gender.
Chromosomes carry genes.
Genes get shuffled when chromosomes exchange pieces.
Evolution begins with the inheritance of gene variation.
Mendelian laws apply to human beings.
Mendelian genetics cannot fully explain human health and behavior.
DNA and proteins are the molecules of the cell nucleus.
One gene makes one protein.
A gene is made of DNA.
Bacteria and viruses have DNA too.
The DNA molecule is shaped like a twisted ladder.
A half DNA ladder is a template for copying the whole.
RNA is an intermediary between DNA and protein.
DNA words are three letters long.
A gene is a discrete sequence of DNA nucleotides.
The RNA message is sometimes edited.
Some viruses store genetic information in RNA.
RNA was the first genetic molecule.
Some types of mutations are automatically repaired.
A chromosome is a package for DNA.
Higher cells incorporate an ancient chromosome.
Some DNA does not encode protein.
Some DNA can jump.
Genes can be turned on and off.
Genes can be moved between species.
DNA responds to signals from outside the cell.
Different genes are active in different kinds of cells.
Master genes control basic body plans.
Development balances cell growth and death.
A genome is an entire set of genes.
Living things share common genes.
DNA is only the starting point for understanding human biology.
adi_at_dnaftb